web analytics
≡ Menu

When the full time siren wails in parliament

When the full time siren wails in parliament

To the tune of, “chestnuts roasting on an open fire…” And, santa Shorten’s cry, “up Dasher, up Dancer, up Prancer and up Yours.”

As the 2017 session of parliament draws to a close and our special species pack their bags and scarper some will have more to think about that stuffing a frozen turkey. Herein is the state of play in the form of a merry Christmas card to whom it may concern. The defence that ‘everybody does it’ seems inconsequential to the Court of Disputed Returns as some scofflaws have already learned.

At this time the exact number of parliamentarians that may be caught in the Dual/Cit net could go beyond the 13 mentioned in this report—it could reach 20. The image affixed may well prove to be most prophetic indeed!

All in all, as many as 13 MPs face referral to the High Court as a result of today’s citizenship disclosures.

They are:

•Labor MPs David Feeney, Justine Keay, Josh Wilson and Susan Lamb;

•Coalition MPs Jason Falinski, Josh Frydenberg, Ross Vasta, Nola Marino, Julia Banks, Alex Hawke, Arthur Sinodinos and Michael McCormack; and

•NXT MP Rebekha Sharkie.

And that’s not counting Labor senator Katy Gallagher who, we discovered yesterday, was technically a dual citizen when she was elected because she renounced her dual British citizenship before the last election but it was not registered until six weeks after election day.

So that’s 14 MPs this week.


It has fallen to Mr Dreyfus to speak for the Labor Party on all matters citizenship.

He goes straight on the attack: “We’ve possibly got an unconstitutionally elected government here.”

Mr Dreyfus names seven government MPs the opposition wants referred to the High Court – Jason Falinski, Julia Banks, Energy Minister Josh Frydenberg, Nola Marino, Industry Minister Arthur Sinodinos, junior minister Alex Hawke and Small Business Minister Michael McCormack.


Political reporter Michael Koziol has spoken to Liberal MP Jason Falinski about his predicament (see 5.45 pm post).

“My father was never Polish. You might as well ask me why there’s no confirmation from the Ukranian embassy,” Mr Falinksi told Michael.

“As far as the UK goes, feel free to ask them yourselves. I’m literally not hiding anything.”

Except any actual documentation he’s not a dual citizen.


Finance Minister Mathias Cormann says Opposition Leader Bill Shorten has been exposed as a “dishonest, sanctimonious hypocrite” for claiming Labor MPs had no citizenship issues.

“He forgot he owned a house. Now he’s forgotten citizenship,”Senator Cormann says of Mr Feeney.

“You can’t tell me Bill Shorten only found out tonight that was the case. You’ve got to assume Bill Shorten has known for some timeDavid Feeney had this problem.”

“It just completely exposes the hypocrisy on this issue.”


Labor’s attorney-general spokesman, Mark Dreyfus, has been asked about his party’s due diligence.

Mr Dreyfus told Radio National just now: “I never suggested that our system was water tight. What I have done is say that it’s rigorous. We’ve got a 12 page questionaire.”

Greens leader Richard Di Natale is exercising admirable restraint about the possibility of a byelection in Mr Feeney’s seat of Batman which could deliver his party its second lower house seat.

“Here we have David Feeney showing a complete lack of integrity, waiting until the last moment and then finally coming clean saying ‘I haven’t got the paperwork’,” Senator Di Natale says.


Remember – the High Court cannot deal with this until next year.

This means a possible sweep of byelections some time in the first half of next year. Probably in late March or April.

With marginal seats now in play (such as Mr Vasta’s Queensland seat of Bonner) this could be a pseudo federal election. Dare one say a referendum on the Turnbull government.


But wait, there’s more – Liberal MPs Ross Vasta and Nola Marinoboth assert they have been told they are not dual Italian citizens.

But neither of them have any paperwork to back this up.

Which is not good enough.

This has been going on for nearly six months. The Prime Ministergave MPs several weeks to get their paperwork in order. One has to assume if they don’t have the paperwork, then they are not in the clear.


That would make Mr Feeney MP number 10.

Coming in at number 11 looks like Sydney MP Jason Falinski.

He has sworn repeatedly he is not a dual Polish citizen.

But all Mr Falinksi has provided by way of paperwork is an assertion he “sought legal advice from [legal firm] Arnold Block Leibler to confirm my citizenship status solely as an Australian citizen”.

He does not have anything more than that. Not even a letter from him to the Polish embassy asking whether he is a citizen.


Mr Feeney has just told Parliament if the documents cannot be located he will refer himself to the High Court.

“I accept I have been unable to produce the requisite notification on renunciation,” Mr Feeney says.

“My status as a citizen in UK law is unclear.”


Good grief.

Mr Feeney is in big trouble.

If he is found to be ineligible, as looks almost certain, that will cause a byelection in the Melbourne seat of Batman.

This seat is highly sought after by the Greens, and they almost won in at the last federal election.


“In November 2017, I sought confirmation form the British Home Office about my 2007 renunciation. Further inquiries are being made of the British Home Office to confirm receipt of my renunciation,” Mr Feeney said.

“In November 2017, I sought confirmation from the Irish Ambassador about my renunciation of any Irish citizenship I may have had in 2007. Further inquiries are being made of the Irish embassy to confirm receipt of my renunciation of any entitlement to Irish citizenship.”

“I have sought advice from the ALP national secretariat in respect of access to historical electronic documents from the time of my nomination as a senator for Victoria in 2007. Those searches are ongoing.”

“I November 2017, I also sough independent Australian legal advice to confirm my status. Without waiving legal professional privilege in that advice, I am not an Irish citizen, nor have I ever been entitled to the rights or privileges of being an Irish citizen and I have taken reasonable steps to renounce my British citizenship.”


Way back in 2007, Mr Feeney sought legal advice before he nominated for the Senate about his possible dual British and/or Irish citizenship status.

He was pretty sure wasn’t a dual Irish citizen but was possibly a dual British citizen because his father was born in Northern Ireland.

“At that time, in October 2007, I signed documents prepared for me in accordance with that advice as to the steps that I needed to take to renounce any inherited British and Irish citizenships,” Mr Feeney wrote.

“As far as I am aware, those documents were sent to the relevant British and Irish authorities as required at the time.”

But he did not check this until last month. That’s right people – TEN YEARS LATER.


Here’s someone who never appeared on anyone’s list previously – Labor MP David Feeney says he has never received confirmation he renounced his UK citizenship.

You might remember Mr Feeneyfrom the 2016 election campaign when he caused Opposition Leader Bill Shorten a world of pain due to his failure to declare a $2.31 million property.

Mr Feeney later blamed a “maelstrom of events” for the oversight.


A quick scan shows Labor MP Josh Wilson was a dual UK citizen at the time he nominated. His renunciation did not come through until later.

Labor MP Susan Lamb says the British Home Office told her it “cannot be satisfied” she held British citizenship.


For those playing at home – the MPs with some questions about their citizenship are Susan Lamb, Rebekha Sharkie, Alex Hawke, Ann Sudmalis, Julia Banks, Nola Marino and Tony Pasin.


The time is now, the place is here!

The citizenship paperwork for lower house MPs has been released.

You can find it here – feel free to have a look and let us know if you see anything fishy.


Minute by minute, the House of Representatives is getting through the same-sex marriage speeches.

Greens MP Adam Bandt has paused for a moment’s silence to remember the LGBTIQ people who have died.


Not surprisingly, GetUp! feels it is being unfairly targeted by the Turnbull government’s new foreign interference legislations.

“This bill does nothing to address the influence big business has on our politicians. The rivers of gold flowing from corporate donors like Adani, Exxon and Chevron stay open and industry bodies like the Minerals Council of Australia can continue to campaign unimpeded. In stark contrast, the government is trying to weaken organisations that represent and support everyday people,” the organisation’s national director, Paul Oosting, said.

“The Turnbull government has sought to attack civil society organisations who advocate for children, the homeless and our environment and to cut off their ability to scrutinise government policy.”


There is a whisper the lower house MPs’ citizenship paperworkwill be available shortly.

Stay tuned.

{ 13 comments… add one }
  • Lorraine 06/12/2017, 7:14 am

    They are all illegal and they have been taking our money and making laws of the land for all to abide by. and they are all above section 44. they all signed stat decs to get in the trough and snuffle snuffle they will not leave. The perks are so good. give me a break I deserve for you to just believe me.

  • Pensioner Pete 06/12/2017, 7:41 am

    Time to dissolve both houses of parliament and hold general elections, not only to end this farcical situation, but to give we, the voters, the opportunity to re-set the game in the hope we obtain government which will actually govern for the majority.

    • Albert 06/12/2017, 7:49 am

      Yes indeed, PP.

    • Gregoryno6 07/12/2017, 8:29 am


    • Ibbit 07/12/2017, 8:38 am

      A most sensible suggestion totally beyond the capabilities of our government. PP for PM.

  • Zoltan 06/12/2017, 7:42 am

    I’d best get round the Lotto offices pronto, I’ve proof on the back of a fag packet that I won $40 million last week!

  • Muphin 06/12/2017, 7:52 am

    Pensioner Pete .. Agree, dissolve both house , election and a referendum to change citizenship laws.

    Unfortunately it WON’T happen, Turncoat knows he will loose.

  • Tony W 06/12/2017, 7:56 am

    I’m uncertain how I came by this quote, it seems appropriate: “Don’t confuse me with the facts. I’ve already made up my mind. I don’t need the truth explained to me”.

    • MM Ed 06/12/2017, 8:17 am

      This might help.
      In May 1954 a Chicago Tribune article discussed an advertising man named Fred Gymer who distributed a monthly letter containing humorous mottoes. None of the example mottoes listed were provided with attributions. The following motto appeared in one of Gymer’s letters: 3

      My Mind Is Made Up—Don’t Confuse Me with Facts.

      • Tony W 06/12/2017, 10:54 am

        Thanks ED, I went to the ‘Quote Investigator’ site – interesting, keep me of the street for a few hours…

  • Biking Voter 06/12/2017, 10:13 am

    Labor Senator Katy Gallagher blamed the government’s “hostile referral threats” for the need for her matter to be dealt with in the High Court.

    Yes, there you have it! Labor always needs someone or something to blame as nothing is ever their fault.

    • Joe Blogs 06/12/2017, 11:39 am

      She’s quit her front bench gigs.

      Those fools who delinquently or fraudulently submitted their citizenship docs – or any other docs related to their roles as candidates or parliamentarians – are unfit for the role and should be tipped out of the joint and never allowed to return.

      If they were applying for a job and submitted a fraudulent application, they could be charged. That should also apply forthwith to politicians and especially to any leader who guaranteed the bona fides of subordinates that are proved to be fraudulent.

  • Rubyred 07/12/2017, 8:32 am

    The Citizenship fiasco has led me to query how many State Parliament politicians are dual citizens. Does it only apply to Federal Parliament? How many Australians are dual citizens and are they eligible to vote?

Leave a Comment